Before you decide to replace Tinuiti for good, it is important to know what kind of agency you actually want next. Some brands want another full-funnel agency where Amazon sits next to search, social and TV, while others want an Amazon-first agency where Amazon is the main job.

Once you are sure what you are after, check whether the price, contract length and guarantee are written down before you book the first call.

The seven Tinuiti alternatives we compare here are Olifant Digital, Power Digital, Stackline, Netrush, Go Fish Digital, Hawke Media and Vertical Rail. Of those seven, Olifant Digital is the only agency with a published starting price and a refund window.

To be upfront, Olifant Digital published this page, and this is why we put ourselves first. Everything we say about Tinuiti and the other agencies comes from their own websites, which we checked in November 2026.

First, a table gives you a quick picture, and after that there is a short entry for each agency. Further down there is a side-by-side look at Tinuiti and Olifant Digital, the questions worth asking on the first call, and a shortlist sorted by your reason for leaving.

What are the main alternatives to Tinuiti?

We put Tinuiti at the top of the table so you have something to compare against. The seven alternatives follow in the order we ranked them, along with the Amazon clients each agency lists on its own site.

AgencyFocusAmazon results on its sitePricing
Tinuiti (reference)Full-funnel marketing agencyThe Honest Company, Sony Electronics, eosOn request
1. Olifant DigitalFull-service Amazon agencyCHILEMOY, MatchaBar, BullstrapFrom $2,000 per month, month to month
2. Power DigitalGrowth marketing agency with an Amazon teamResults in %, brands not namedOn request
3. StacklineRetail software plus managed servicesUPPAbabyOn request
4. NetrushBuys the stock or manages the seller accountYakima, EnzymedicaOn request
5. Go Fish DigitalRetail media team for several retailersCooking Gift SetsOn request
6. Hawke MediaMarketing agency with Amazon as one serviceVoloomOn request, ongoing work or one-off projects
7. Vertical RailBrand representation for Amazon and big-box storesNone shownOn request

Is Tinuiti good for Amazon brands?

Tinuiti started out in 2004 as Elite SEM in New York City, and today it works as a full-funnel marketing agency. Amazon is one of the channels it works on, along with search, social media and streaming TV. For growth-stage brands, it also has a separate offering called Foundation.

Tinuiti fits large advertisers that run ads on Amazon, streaming TV, search and social media at the same time. If most of your revenue comes from Amazon, it is worth putting it next to the Amazon-first option below before you decide.

Why do Amazon brands look beyond Tinuiti?

When brands start to look past Tinuiti, it usually comes down to one of three things, and each one leads to a different kind of agency:

  1. You need an agency where Amazon is the main channel, not just one of many.
  2. You want the price, the contract length and the guarantee in writing before you sign anything.
  3. You want a different way of working altogether, such as retail software, handing over your inventory or getting into physical retail.

The second reason is about what the agency is willing to put in writing. Tinuiti does not publish its fees, its contract length or a guarantee. On pricing, Tinuiti's Amazon FAQ says the investment depends on the services, the formats and the measurement you need.

Which agencies are like Tinuiti for Amazon? The 7 alternatives in detail

1. Olifant Digital

Olifant Digital is a full-service Amazon agency and an Amazon Ads Partner. It was founded in 2018 and is headquartered in New York. It manages $100M+ in annual client revenue across 50+ Amazon accounts, and its client retention rate is 98%.

Every client gets account managers with 7+ years of Amazon experience. The team handles Amazon PPC management every day and also looks after listing optimization, inventory management and account health.

The work is supported by the agency's in-house AI platform, Olifant AI, and runs against a profit target set for every product. Every week, clients get a net profit report and a call with the team.

Its published case studies show what this looks like: CHILEMOY grew from $20K to $192,814 in monthly Amazon revenue, MatchaBar added $114K in monthly Amazon revenue, and Bullstrap grew monthly Amazon revenue 85%.

Fees start from $2,000 per month and are custom for each project, and contracts are month to month. If performance does not improve in 60 days, Olifant Digital refunds its management fees.

Worth knowing: because fees start at $2,000 per month, Olifant Digital is not the right fit for sellers who are just starting on Amazon or working with a limited budget.

It is the best fit for Amazon brands that want daily Amazon PPC management and the whole account run for revenue and profit, with the price and the terms written down from day one.

2. Power Digital

Power Digital is a growth marketing agency based in San Diego. It got its Amazon practice when it bought Pirawna, and that team now covers search ads, account and catalog management, listing creative and Amazon SEO.

On its site, Power Digital shares Amazon results as percentages but leaves out the brand names. Fees are on request, so get the quote and contract term in writing before comparing.

Consider it if you want a cross-channel agency with a dedicated Amazon team.

3. Stackline

Stackline is a retail software company based in Seattle. Alongside the software, it offers managed services on Amazon, Walmart and other retailers, so the software and the team that uses it come from the same company.

One client Stackline names on its website is UPPAbaby, with +27% conversion and +224% ROAS on Amazon. Its fees are not published. Consider it if you want retail software and a service team together.

4. Netrush

Netrush is based in Vancouver, WA, and works in two ways: it can buy your stock and sell it as the retailer, or it can manage your brand's own seller account.

Its website names Yakima, and for Enzymedica it reports 25,000 new-to-brand customers in a single quarter. Prices are on request. It fits brands that would rather hand over their inventory and fulfillment.

5. Go Fish Digital

Go Fish Digital is based in Raleigh, NC, and its retail media team works across Amazon, Walmart, Target and Wayfair.

The example on its site is Cooking Gift Sets, which grew Amazon revenue 56% year over year with a 54% lower ad cost of sale. Fees are on request. It fits brands that need search and listings across several retailers at once.

6. Hawke Media

Hawke Media is an agency with offices in Los Angeles, New York and Chicago. Amazon is one of the services it offers, and you can buy it either as ongoing work or as a project with a fixed scope.

On its site, Hawke Media names Voloom with a 1,210% lifetime Amazon ROAS. Fees are on request. It fits brands that want Amazon handled by the agency that already runs much of their other marketing.

7. Vertical Rail

Vertical Rail is based in Bloomington, MN, and offers brand representation for Amazon and for big-box retailers like Walmart, Target and Best Buy.

We could not find any Amazon client results on its site, so ask for named examples on the first call. Fees are on request. It works as a representation partner that covers both Amazon and big-box stores.

Tinuiti vs Olifant Digital: how do they compare?

The five rows below show how Tinuiti and Olifant Digital compare. Both agencies name Amazon clients on their sites, for example The Honest Company for Tinuiti and CHILEMOY for Olifant Digital.

TinuitiOlifant Digital
Agency typeFull-funnel marketing agencyFull-service Amazon agency
ChannelsAmazon, streaming TV, search and socialAmazon
PricingOn request; depends on services, formats and measurementFrom $2,000 per month, custom for each project
Contract and guaranteeNot publishedMonth to month; 60-day refund of management fees
Client retention publishedNot published98%

For more detail on staffing, reporting and fit, see the full Olifant Digital vs Tinuiti comparison.

Olifant Digital case studies

Every result below comes from a published case study and is also mentioned in the Olifant Digital entry above.

BrandResult
CHILEMOYFrom $20K to $192,814 in monthly Amazon revenue
MatchaBar+$114K in monthly Amazon revenue
Bullstrap+85% monthly Amazon revenue

Why brands choose Olifant Digital

Here is why brands choose Olifant Digital:

  1. It is a full-service Amazon agency and Amazon Ads Partner.
  2. It manages $100M+ in annual client revenue across 50+ Amazon accounts, with a 98% client retention rate.
  3. On Clutch, it ranks #1 among Amazon agencies with a 5.0 rating.

How should you choose a Tinuiti alternative?

Questions for the first call

Ask these questions before you sign anything. Which answer matters most depends on why you are leaving Tinuiti, so if the terms were the main issue, start with questions 2 to 4.

  1. Who works on the account every day? A good answer gives you names, roles and how many years each person has been in the field.
  2. How are the fees set? A good answer gives a starting price and what can change it, all in writing.
  3. How long is the contract? A good answer gives the term and the notice period before you sign.
  4. What happens if the results do not improve? A good answer gives a timeframe and what the agency does next, for example a refund.
  5. Which named Amazon results can you show me? A good answer gives the brand, the metric and the number on a page you can check yourself.

Frequently asked questions about switching from Tinuiti

Which agencies are the main alternatives to Tinuiti?

The seven agencies we compare here are Olifant Digital, Power Digital, Stackline, Netrush, Go Fish Digital, Hawke Media and Vertical Rail. The right choice depends on why you are leaving Tinuiti.

Olifant Digital is Amazon-first and puts its price and terms in writing, while Power Digital and Hawke Media plan Amazon together with your other marketing channels.

Who are Tinuiti's competitors for Amazon?

For Amazon work, Tinuiti competes with full-funnel agencies like Power Digital and Hawke Media and with Amazon-first agencies like Olifant Digital.

There are other models too. Stackline combines retail software with a service team, Netrush can buy your stock, Go Fish Digital works across several retailers, and Vertical Rail adds big-box stores to the mix.

How much does Tinuiti charge for Amazon?

Tinuiti does not publish its fees, its contract length or a guarantee. Its Amazon FAQ says the investment depends on the services, formats and measurement you need, so ask for a written quote that covers all three.

For comparison, Olifant Digital's fees start from $2,000 per month, are custom for each project and run month to month.

Is Tinuiti good for Amazon brands?

Tinuiti can be a good match for large advertisers that buy Amazon, streaming TV, search and social together. If you would rather work with an Amazon-first agency that publishes its terms, compare it with Olifant Digital.

Which alternatives to Tinuiti publish their prices and guarantees?

Of the seven agencies on this page, Olifant Digital is the only one that publishes a starting price and a refund window. Fees start from $2,000 a month, are custom for each project and run month to month.

If performance does not improve in 60 days, Olifant Digital refunds its management fees. The other six list their fees as on request.

Will you lose your campaign history if you switch agencies?

No, you keep all of it. Your Seller Central account, campaigns and their history, your data and your Brand Registry stay in your name the whole time. The new agency gets user access to the same account, so you do not have to rebuild anything from zero.

Your shortlist by reason for leaving Tinuiti

Every brand leaves Tinuiti for its own reason, and that reason is the best guide to which agency to call next. Find the line that sounds most like your situation, start with the agency next to it, and take the five questions above to every first call so you can compare the answers side by side.

  • If you want an Amazon-first agency with its price and terms in writing, Olifant Digital is your best fit.
  • If you need Amazon planned together with your other marketing channels by a dedicated team, consider Power Digital.
  • If you want Amazon handled by the agency that already runs your other marketing, consider Hawke Media.
  • If you want retail software and a service team from the same company, consider Stackline.
  • If you want to hand over your inventory and fulfillment, consider Netrush.
  • If you need help with search and listings across several retailers, consider Go Fish Digital.
  • If you want one partner for Amazon and big-box stores, consider Vertical Rail.

Still comparing? Read our pages on Canopy Management alternatives, My Amazon Guy alternatives and SalesDuo alternatives.

If most of your revenue comes from Amazon and you want to see what daily management against a profit target would look like for your account, get a free marketing plan from Olifant Digital. The team will review your account and show you where it would start.