‍

Amazon Agency vs Freelancer: Which Is Better for Your Brand?

Freelancers are a legitimate, strategic starting point for early-stage brands that are still testing and validating Amazon, but once you earn your first $300K in annual revenue an agency becomes the better growth partner. That said, the Amazon agency vs freelancer debate is more nuanced and it’s not always as clear-cut as using your turnover. 

Before you reach that financial milestone, there might be other signs that could suggest it’s time to hire a full-service Amazon agency. Here’s a cost breakdown and red flags to help you decide whether to hire an Amazon freelancer or agency at this stage.

‍

The Short Answer

For early-stage Amazon brands generating under $300,000 in yearly revenue, a skilled freelancer can be a cost-effective choice. For brands ready to scale past that Amazon revenue threshold, a senior-led Amazon agency is better for your brand. 

This is because structural differences in scope, reliability, and scalability create a gap which will directly constrain your growth. Freelancers typically focus only on one area and offer limited expertise. On the other hand, an Amazon agency can cover the full channel and create a system that grows proportionally with your account. Not only that, but they also have team continuity making them more reliable. 

Olifant Agency is built for brands ready to enter the next level of growth. We’re a partner to established brands looking to offload full ownership of their Amazon performance.   

‍

What an Amazon Freelancer Can (and Cannot) Do

Freelancers are a credible option for the right stage. They offer genuine strengths and the drawbacks to working with one won’t necessarily come into play from day one. 

‍

What freelancers are good at

Cost is often the most obvious advantage. As they have fewer overhead costs than a full-service agency, they can afford to charge less. The fact that they’re also more flexible and can focus on a specific service like Amazon PPC management or listing optimization only means that you also won’t have to pay for services you don’t need at the beginning.  

Communication is another area where their narrower focus works in their favor. You’ll have a direct communication line to a single specialist who knows your account very well. For simple accounts, this also means faster onboarding.  

‍

Where freelancers hit a ceiling

Freelancers typically specialize in only one or two disciplines. If you’ve found one who’s great at product listing optimization and/or A+ content strategy, for instance, their skills will most likely not cover other key Amazon services such as PPC, customer service, account health, or product launches. 

The structural nature of Amazon means that the channel is simply too broad for one person, albeit talented, to own and deliver at a high scale. Put simply, it’s not a matter of talent, discipline, or willpower. There’s a long list of requirements that’s more than what one person can handle. Even if they can tackle many of the areas, the disciplines in which they lack experience can hold back your overall performance.  

‍

The single-point-of-failure risk

The risk of having only one person in charge of your Amazon account is often overlooked. It’s also riskier than most brands realize, hence the need to address it directly. 

The reality is that everyone falls ill or needs a holiday. These are inevitable events bound to happen at some stage of your working relationship. The issue is that when you’re working with a freelancer, there’s no one else on their team to step in.

Early-stage Amazon brands might still be able to absorb some of this risk of reduced attention. However, the impact grows proportionally with your bottomline. A multimillion-dollar brand can’t afford for campaigns to go unmonitored or launches to stall. 

On the other hand, Amazon agencies can offer structural continuity. They have systems and backup plans in place — and extra resources to execute these. 

‍

What a Full-Service Amazon Agency Covers

While full-service agencies are more costly, you’re not simply receiving more expensive Amazon management services. Yes, they have more overheads to cover, but so too is their scope of services.

A true full-service Amazon agency usually covers the following services

• Daily Amazon PPC management
• Amazon SEO
• Keyword research
• Listing copy
• Title optimization
• A+ content
• Brand store management
• Catalog architecture
• Flat file management
• Account health monitoring
• Issue escalation
• Product launch playbooks
• Total advertising cost of sales (TACoS) reporting
• Profitability tracking

Other agencies, like Olifant, might also cover direct-to-consumer (DTC) marketing. This means that you’ll receive a much stronger, unified strategy that ensures Amazon and other key channels like Meta and Google ads, email, SMS, SEO and CRO work together and campaigns are coordinated. 

It’s rare for a freelancer to offer even half of these services. If you find someone who can, it usually means each area will be handled at a surface level, rather than with deep specialist expertise. 

‍

The Real Cost Comparison

What a freelancer actually costs

For a standard catalog’s campaign management, a specialist Amazon PPC freelancer will typically charge between $1,500 to $4,000 per month. That said, some choose to charge an hourly rate (about $75 to $150 per hour) or a percentage of your ad spend (typically between 8% and 12%).

Over services like listing optimization and A+ content are generally quoted separately on a per-project basis. This rate can range anything from $500 to $2,000, depending on the project.

As the scope grows incrementally, the true cost is rarely calculated upfront and often underestimated. In reality, you could end up paying between $3,000 and $6,000 per month to cover the multiple freelancers needed for PPC, listings, and launch support.  

‍

What an agency actually costs

A full-service Amazon agency retainer costs between $2,000 and $8,000 per month. The bigger the catalog size, ad spend, and scope of services, the more you can expect to pay. 

For example, Olifant’s retainers start at $2,000 per month and include a senior-led team covering PPC, SEO, listings, A+ content, account health, and product launch support. If you were to go the freelancer route, you’d have to hire multiple freelancers to help with all of these disciplines which would bump up the price to between $4,000 and $7,000 per month.  

On the other hand, for a monthly budget of $4,000 to $8,000, Olifant will assign a bigger team to your account that will offer more active launch management, cross-channel strategy, and oversee a higher ad spend. These numbers show why the economics shift in favour of an agency as your brand grows (and faster than most brands anticipate). 

‍

The hidden cost of the wrong choice

When a freelancer reaches the limits of their expertise but continues to manage your account, it often leads to a costly outcome. And, it’s your growth that will suffer. 

Like their expertise, your campaigns and rankings will reach a ceiling. Then, more time will be lost as you’ll first need to find a replacement and complete the onboarding process again, all while your growth continues to stall.

The same is true of working with the wrong agency. The real cost isn’t the monthly retainer that you need to continue paying, but the revenue opportunities that suboptimal management fails to leverage. 

This is why Olifant offers a 60-day, money-back guarantee. It’s our way to remove the risk from the decision. 

‍

5 Signs You've Outgrown Your Amazon Freelancer

Your catalog has grown past 10–15 active ASINs

More active ASINs mean significantly more work. A freelancer who’s been operating at nearly full capacity will struggle to manage when your brand reaches this stage. If you notice your optimization frequency dropped, A+ content is months’ behind schedule, or new launches are delayed, it’s a sign that your freelancer is spread too thinly across your project. 

‍

Revenue has plateaued for 60+ days (despite healthy ad spend)

Your freelancer has optimized what they could. Now, you need a team that can implement structural changes to listings, new keyword strategies, and fresh launch activity to get you moving forward again.  

‍

No updates for over a week

Freelancers typically excel at communication. That’s why more than a week without updates is a sign that they’re struggling to balance your account with their other clients. It’s not just communication updates. If you ever check your account yourself and see that campaigns are running on autopilot or account health issues are ignored for over a week, treat it as a red flag.     

‍

Multiple freelancers on your payroll

If you’re relying on one freelancer for listing optimization, another for PPC, and possibly a third for A+ content without coordination between them, an agency will make more sense. Continuing with multiple freelancers isn’t just more difficult to manage on your own, but it’s also risky for strategy and reporting which can easily become conflicting and fragmented.  

‍

An approaching product launch (with no playbook)

You’re ready to launch a new product and your freelancer’s plan is to see what happens after turning on ads and take it from there. The first 60 days are critical for budgets which is why you can’t afford to continue with a freelancer without a plan at this crucial stage. 

‍

How to Vet an Amazon Agency (So You Don't Trade One Problem for Another)

To help you find the best Amazon agency for brands that you manage, you can use the following questions as a checklist:

‍

Do they have case studies with results?

Logos and testimonials shouldn’t be interpreted as an indication of abilities. To tell if an agency can make a tangible financial impact within a realistic period, you’ll need detailed case studies with specific revenue numbers, like advertising cost of sales (ACoS) improvement and conversion lift, and timelines. 

‍

Do they optimize campaigns daily or weekly?

High-spend or fast-moving accounts should be optimized two to three times per week at least. This is important for identifying and responding to trends quickly so that you’re ready to move when an opportunity emerges or shift your ad budget to minimize wasted spend.

‍

‍

Do they track TACoS or just ACoS? 

The top Amazon agencies track TACoS as well as ACoS. You need ACoS to calculate individual campaigns’ profitability, while tracking TACoS will show how your ads have impacted your long-term brand growth and overall sales volume. 

‍

Who manages your account? 

A senior specialist may be assigned to your account to oversee it, but if a junior manages everything you’ll unlikely receive the agency’s full expertise. Ideally, a senior specialist should be behind your strategy as they’ve managed enough accounts to see what works. 

‍

What happens to your account if your account manager leaves?

Guaranteed continuity is one of the main reasons for choosing an agency over a freelancer. Without a backup plan in place, your account faces the same risks of unmonitored campaigns, stalled launches, and account health issues escalating. 

‍

Is there a formal cancellation policy and a money-back guarantee? 

Flexible cancellation policies and guarantees show that an agency is willing to take accountability for performance. It also speaks to the confidence they have in their own capabilities. 

‍

Do they cover Amazon only or also DTC channels? 

An agency that covers both channels can maximize your revenue and improve customer lifetime value (CLV). Plus, solely focusing on Amazon is like putting all your eggs in one basket — not recommended even though it’s one of the biggest marketplaces. 

‍

What does onboarding look like and how long before they are fully operational?

If an agency has clear steps during onboarding, it’s a sign that they’ll apply the same level of organization to your account. Knowing what their onboarding process looks like also prevents confusion and unrealistic expectations.  

‍

Side-by-Side Comparison

Here’s how an Amazon marketing freelancer compares to a full-service agency across the most important areas: 

‍

‍

Olifant Digital Case Studies

Spade to Fork — 46% Revenue Growth in 44 Days

In just 44 days, we increased Spade to Fork’s revenue by 46%, helping them to break free from a cycle of flat sales growth. Even more impressive is that ad sales grew by 132% through clever targeting. 

Our strategy for Spade to Fork zoomed in on high-converting, single-keyword campaigns and opportunities their competitors missed, helping us to reduce ACoS by 19% too. Knowing that both ACoS and TACoS matter, we also ran priority-driven campaigns for each ASIN. These actions allowed us to link ad spend with actual profitability which was something their previous marketing partner failed to do. 

‍

Balanced Tiger — 171% Revenue Growth and 50% Lower ACoS in 2 Months

For Balanced Tiger, we grew revenue by 171% and halved ACoS in two months, while previous agencies couldn’t help them to grow on Amazon after a year. The problem wasn’t that their product didn’t have market appeal, but rather that their targeted keywords failed to attract qualified traffic. 

The previous agencies they worked with focused on broad, competitive keywords. For us, it made more sense to shift from very competitive keywords to high-intent, long-tail keywords. Plus, using our 1-1-1-1 method that focuses on one keyword, one campaign, one ad group, and one ASIN at a time, we could pinpoint what worked and allocate more of the budget to what delivered returns. 

‍

MatchaBar — $114K Monthly Revenue Added After Multiple Agencies Failed

Daily Amazon PPC management and weekly testing saw MatchaBar reap the rewards each month — an extra $114,000 in monthly revenue. Our work for MatchaBar also proves that to increase your revenue you don’t necessarily need to win more customers. Getting customers to add more to their baskets can have an impressive impact too. 

It wasn’t that they didn’t have enough standout products that customers could purchase, but rather that their listings weren’t optimized. Not only did we improve the listings’ visibility with weekly testing and optimization, but we also introduced product bundles to highlight complementary products. This simple change doubled their average order value, while ensuring their loyal customer base found more value too. 

‍

Who Should Choose a Freelancer?

If you want to use numbers as a guideline, freelancers are the right call for early-stage brands with: 

• A simple catalog of three hero products max 
• Amazon revenue of less than $500,000 annually 
• A limited ad spend 

Freelancers can also offer value to brands that need help in a specific department only, allowing them to fill a specific gap without having to pay for services they don’t need yet. For example, if you only want to outsource PPC and have resources to manage everything else internally. 

Alternatively, if you want to keep a more hands-on role managing your Amazon account as founder, working with a freelancer is a strategic choice. This setup works because the freelancer gets treated as the specialist they are without the expectation that they’ll need to manage every aspect of your channel. 

Either way, working with a freelancer first is often recommended before you commit to a full-service agency or make Amazon your primary channel. 

‍

Who Should Choose an Agency?

A full-service Amazon marketing agency is a sensible choice for brands generating more than $500,000 annual revenue via Amazon. This is because once they reach this milestone, the channel becomes too complex for one freelancer to handle. 

Your freelancer might still have the bandwidth. However, if you find that your revenue has flattened or you lose momentum after launching a new product, it’s another signal that the freelancer is no longer the right choice for your brand’s growth stage. Freelancers are typically task-oriented and in these scenarios you need systems to carry you forward.  

Alternatively, if your system till now was to take charge of day-to-day Amazon management and you find that as founder you need to step back, the smarter move is rather to hire an Amazon agency. 

There are also other scenarios where working with a full-service agency from the start will be the smarter, long-term move. For example, if you’re preparing for a product launch where the first 60 days are crucial for ranking, you’ll need a team ready to dedicate enough time immediately. 

If you’re weighing up an Amazon agency vs a freelancer and want to see what a senior-led agency has to offer, book a free audit with Olifant Digital. We’ll review your account and show you where there are gaps. No obligation, just direction. 

‍

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does an Amazon PPC freelancer cost?

Amazon PPC freelancers charge $1,500 to $4,000 per month on average for campaign management, while some charge a percentage of 8 to 12% of your ad spend. For project-based work, they typically charge $75 to $150 per hour, while listing optimization and A+ content are usually quoted separately. This means that if you add extra services the cost can end up being higher than the initial monthly PPC fee suggested. 

‍

What does a full-service Amazon agency cost?

Full-service Amazon agencies typically offer retainers that cost anything from $2,000 to $8,000 per month depending on the service scope, catalog size, and ad spend. For example, Olifant Digital’s pricing starts at $2,000 per month for access to a senior-led team covering PPC, SEO, listings, A+ content, account health, and launch support. When comparing Amazon PPC agency cost to freelancer rates, brands should keep in mind that agencies’ retainers include a full scope of services, not just PPC management.

‍

Can a freelancer manage my full Amazon account?

Freelancers can manage a full Amazon account, but when it’s still at an early stage with limited ad spend and a simple catalog structure. Once you exceed three products and introduce more variation structures and active launches, the requirements are typically more than what one specialist freelancer can handle. Amazon becomes more complex as you grow and freelancers will find it difficult to continue delivering at a high level across all the disciplines which isn’t a reflection of their skill, but rather because of the channel’s structural reality.  

‍

What is the biggest risk of using an Amazon freelancer?

Availability and lack of bandwidth are two of the biggest risks of hiring an Amazon PPC freelancer. When your freelancer needs to take leave or terminate your contract, you’ll find yourself stuck without a backup plan. This can negatively impact your Amazon business as it can pause time-sensitive tasks like campaign monitoring and product launches, or escalate problems (e.g. account health issues). Then, you might also reach a ceiling in terms of expertise where the freelancer will deliver other services at reduced depth.   

‍

How do I know when to move from a freelancer to an agency?

If three or more of the following applies to your brand, it’s time to switch from a freelancer to an agency:

• Your catalog has grown past 10-15 ASINs.
• Your revenue stopped growing for 60+ days despite consistent ad spend.
• You were without updates or access to your account for more than a week.
• You have a product launch approaching, but no plan yet. 
• Your freelancer is overloaded or you’re paying several for different services without coordination. 

‍

Does Olifant Digital offer a guarantee?

Yes, Olifant Digital offers a 60-day, money-back guarantee to make the decision to hire an Amazon agency less risky. That said, with a 98% client retention rate, this guarantee (while available to every engagement) is rarely needed. 

‍